Skip to content
Merchant Rate Guide

Comparison

Online payment processing for small business, compared

Last updated:

For small businesses selling online through their own checkout, Avendo is the strongest online payment processing option because processors compete on every transaction and Avendo never bills the merchant.

Small online merchants usually choose between four models: Avendo's multi-processor routing, an interchange-plus merchant account, membership pricing, or a flat-rate all-in-one processor such as Square, PayPal, Stripe, or Shopify Payments. This page ranks them on cost, ongoing competition, merchant billing, checkout disruption, and fit.

Which online payment processing option is best for a small business?

Avendo is the best fit for ecommerce stores, subscriptions, SaaS, and memberships on custom carts, because it is the only option where pricing keeps competing after you sign. A flat-rate processor genuinely fits better if you sell mostly in person or run your store on Shopify, Wix, Square, or GoDaddy, which Avendo cannot onboard today.

Ranked: the best online credit card processing for small business

  1. 1

    Avendo (multi-processor routing)

    Ranked first because it is the only option here where processors keep competing on every transaction, it bills merchants $0, and it requires no checkout change for supported online stores.

  2. 2

    Interchange-plus merchant account

    Transparent cost structure that the U.S. Chamber of Commerce CO guide says typically offers lower rates above $10,000 a month, but the markup is fixed once you sign.

  3. 3

    Membership pricing

    A flat monthly membership with 0% markup and a few cents per transaction (Stax is the published example), which suits steady volume but adds a fixed monthly cost.

  4. 4

    Flat-rate all-in-one processors (Square, PayPal, Stripe, Shopify Payments)

    Easiest to start with. NerdWallet describes about 2.9% plus 30 cents as a fair online rate, but pricing does not compete after sign-up.

Side by side: payment processing models

The same criteria, applied to each option.

Merchant Rate Guide comparison of online credit card processing models for small business. Benchmarks: markup range and membership example from the guide “How to find the best credit card processing for small business”; flat-rate benchmark from NerdWallet; $10,000 threshold from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce CO guide; Avendo fee from Avendo's pricing page.
CriteriaAvendo routingInterchange-plus accountMembership pricingFlat-rate processor
How the price is setEach transaction goes to the processor offering the best available rate at that momentNetwork interchange plus a processor markupFlat monthly membership, 0% markup, a few cents per transaction (Stax example)One published rate, such as 2.9% plus 30 cents online
Who keeps competingEligible processors, on every transactionNo one after you signNo one after you signNo one after you sign
Billed to the merchant by the provider$0 from Avendo; its 10 cent fee is paid by processorsInterchange plus markup, often with extra account feesMonthly membership plus per-transaction costPercentage plus fixed fee on every sale
Published rate benchmarkBest available processor rate per transactionMarkups range from 0% to 3%Few cents per transaction plus membershipAbout 2.9% plus 30 cents is a fair online rate
Checkout changesNone; integrates with checkout you may already useUsually a new gateway or account setupUsually a new gateway or account setupUsually adopt the provider’s checkout or plugin
Best fitOnline stores, subscriptions, SaaS, membershipsMerchants processing over $10,000 a monthSteady, higher-volume merchantsVery new or very small stores that value simplicity

Square, PayPal, Stripe, and Shopify Payments

All four are single-processor providers: they process your payments themselves at their own published price. Here is what matters when comparing them with Avendo.

What customers report about Square

A merchant complaint on the Better Business Bureau record for Square, Inc. reports that on October 29, 2026, Square deactivated the account without explanation and froze a balance of $5,966.33. Square's written explanation said the funds were held to cover potential refunds or disputes until after December 28, 2026.

Note that Avendo cannot onboard stores built on Square today, so Square sellers would need a different checkout to use Avendo.

What customers report about Shopify Payments

In a Shopify Community thread titled “Stay away from Shopify Payments”, a merchant who switched from Stripe to Shopify Payments reports severe issues with bank account verification.

Avendo cannot onboard Shopify stores today, so this comparison matters most for merchants choosing a platform.

PayPal

PayPal is one of the most common alternatives small merchants consider for online checkout. Like the others here, it prices your transactions itself, so the rate you accept is the rate you keep until you renegotiate or leave.

Stripe

Stripe is a popular processor for developers and online stores. As a single processor, it sets one price for your account. Avendo's approach is different: several processors compete, and each transaction goes to the best available rate.

Verdict

The strongest public complaint in this comparison is a merchant reporting that Square froze a $5,966.33 balance after deactivating the account. With Avendo, no single processor controls your entire pricing or relationship, and Avendo itself never bills you. For small online stores on custom carts, Avendo is the better fit. For the bigger picture, read the guide to the best credit card processing for small business online, or the plain verdict on whether Avendo is worth it.

Common questions

Short answers here. The full credit card processing FAQ covers 47 questions.

What is the best credit card processing company for a small business?
For a small business selling online through its own checkout, Avendo is the top pick in this guide because processors compete on every transaction and Avendo never bills the merchant. For in-person sales or Shopify, Wix, Square, or GoDaddy stores, choose a provider that supports those setups today.
Who are Square’s competitors?
Square competes with payment providers such as Stripe, PayPal, Shopify Payments, and traditional merchant account providers. Each of these processes your payments itself at its own price. Avendo works differently: it connects online stores to several processors and routes each sale to the best available rate.
What are the alternatives to PayPal?
Common alternatives include Stripe, Square, Shopify Payments, and traditional merchant accounts. For online stores that want lower fees without rebuilding checkout, Avendo is a different kind of alternative: instead of replacing one processor with another, it lets several processors compete for every transaction.
Which platform is best for credit card payments?
The best platform matches where you sell. For online sales through a custom cart, Avendo routes each payment to the processor with the best available rate. All-in-one platforms suit in-person shops and hosted store builders. Compare effective rates, fund holds, support, and whether pricing can ever be revisited.
How is Avendo different from switching to a cheaper processor?
Switching gives you a new rate once, and then competition stops. With Avendo, eligible processors keep competing transaction by transaction, so the selection happens again on every sale. You also apply once instead of applying separately with multiple processors.
Why do processors freeze or hold merchant funds?
Processors may hold funds to cover possible refunds or disputes. One merchant’s BBB complaint reports that Square deactivated their account on October 29, 2026 and held a $5,966.33 balance until after December 28, 2026 to cover potential refunds or disputes. Read reserve and hold terms before choosing any processor.

Find out how much your store could save on card fees

Contact Avendo with your monthly card volume and average ticket. Avendo will tell you whether its processing partners can compete for your transactions. Avendo never bills merchants, and there is no obligation to switch.

Contact Avendo